Evaluation framework to compare the sustainability of different applications of biomass waste

In recent years the demand for biomass as a renewable energy source has increased spectacularly. Biomass has started to play an important role in the production of heat, electricity and bio-fuels, contributing significantly to the achievement of the EU renewable energy objectives. Apart from energy applications, biomass is a versatile resource for food, feed, fibre, construction material or raw material for the chemical industry. As the amount of biomass that can be produced and mobilized in a sustainable way is limited, questions arise on the most optimal and sustainable way to use the available biomass streams.

Further Authors:
M. Uyttebroek - VITO NV, Flemish Institute for Technological Research
N. Devriendt - VITO NV, Flemish Institute for Technological Research
L. Pelkmans - VITO NV, Flemish Institute for Technological Research

It seems obvious to direct the available biomass towards those applications which contribute most towards societal sustainability objectives while avoiding the disturbance of traditional biomassdependent sectors or unwanted side-effects from dedicated support mechanisms. In a recent study VITO developed an evaluation framework which allows policy makers to compare the sustainability of different applications starting from a specific biomass stream, in terms of environmental, economic and social impacts. This means that the performance of different applications in very different sectors needs to be compared based on multiple criteria. For this purpose, a set of eleven indicators is constructed to assess the main sustainability aspects of each application, taking into account the variety of applications for a specific biomass stream. The methodology that is used to do the evaluation is based on the life-cycle thinking (LCT) approach. For each biomass application it is determined which traditional alternative is replaced by the use of biomass as a renewable resource. By measuring or calculating the indicators an evaluation is made of the environmental, economical and social impacts that are avoided or created by replacing the usual alternative with the biomass stream under consideration. Applications in different sectors are compared by evaluating the improvement that can be obtained by dedicating the biomass resource to one or the other application. In order to show its merits and its limitations, the developed methodology and indicator set is applied on the cases of post-consumer wood and rendered animal fat. The most challenging part of applying the methodology is the development of verifiers for every indicator. Some indicators are relatively easy to quantify, while others are not, due to lack of data or measuring methods. Especially the non-environmental indicators (economic and social) have proven to be difficult to quantify. The choice of the avoided alternative processes turned out to be a crucial element in the results. The differences in net impact between the studied applications of biomass waste are largely dominated by the choice of the alternative processes or primary materials that are avoided by the use of the biomass stream, stressing the importance of a sound market analysis to identify the marginal alternative process that will be replaced. In practice, the alternative process that is replaced depends on existing policies concerning renewable energy and the local market forces of demand and supply.

Copyright: © European Compost Network ECN e.V.
Quelle: Orbit 2012 (Juni 2012)
Seiten: 7
Preis inkl. MwSt.: € 7,00
Autor: K. Vanbroekhoven
Saskia Manshoven
Ive Vanderreydt

Artikel weiterleiten In den Warenkorb legen Artikel kommentieren

Diese Fachartikel könnten Sie auch interessieren:

Umweltbildung mit #wirfuerbio
© Witzenhausen-Institut für Abfall, Umwelt und Energie GmbH (4/2023)
#wirfuerbio ist die bundesweite Kampagne der kommunalen Abfallwirtschaft zur Reduzierung von Störstoffen im Bioabfall. Mit einer starken Bandbreite unterschiedlicher crossmedialer Kommunikationsmittel und Maßnahmen verändert sich das Verhalten der Biotonnenbenutzer. Die Störstoffquote sinkt um mehr als 50 Prozent. Die Kampagne weist einen neuen Weg in der Umweltbildung. Mit der Abfallbox und der SpieleApp „#wirfuerbio das Sortierspiel“ wird Kreislaufwirtschaft in Form von Spaß und Spiel erlebbar. Der Beitrag zeigt, wie Abfallbox und Spiele-App didaktisch funktionieren und ein Bewusstsein für Kreislaufwirtschaft und Mülltrennung entwickeln.

Feldversuche zum Abbauverhalten von kompostierbaren Vorsammelhilfen in der technischen Kompostierung
© Witzenhausen-Institut für Abfall, Umwelt und Energie GmbH (4/2023)
Kompostierbare Vorsammelhilfen (zertifiziert nach EN 13432 und „OK Compost Home“) wurden zwei Versuchsmieten in „realitätsnahen“ Mengen zugesetzt, wobei eine theoretische Befüllung von 1 bis 1,2 kg Bioabfall pro Vorsammelhilfe erreicht wurde. Die Vorsammelhilfen fragmentierten bereits in den ersten beiden Rottewochen und verschwanden zwischen der zweiten und der vierten Woche in der Fraktion > 10 mm vollständig. Geringe Partikelanzahlen vom Typ der untersuchten Vorsammelhilfen konnten in der Fraktion 0,63 bis 0,2 mm in der Anlage 1 nach neun Wochen und in Anlage 2 nach zwölf Wochen nachgewiesen werden, wodurch gezeigt werden konnte, dass die untersuchten Vorsammelhilfen während der ordnungsgemäßen Kompostierung kaum zu Mikrokunststoffen fragmentiert.

Development of local municipal solid waste management in the Western Transdanubia region of Hungary
© Lehrstuhl für Abfallverwertungstechnik und Abfallwirtschaft der Montanuniversität Leoben (11/2020)
Hungarian municipal solid wastes (MSW) management has developed tremendously over the past 15 years. More than 3,000 landfills and dumps had been closed, just to mention one improvement. However, still, lots of work is necessary to accomplish the EU’s ambitious aim of decreasing landfilling and increasing recycling and composting.

Compost-like material or thermal valorization – impact on MBT Plant economics and environmental aspects – Case studies in Portugal and UK
© Wasteconsult International (5/2015)
The paper focuses on the utilisation of the solid product from the biological Treatment stages of three MBT Plants which treat the organic fraction of MSW by means of wet mechanical pre-treatment units followed by anaerobic digestion. The experiences of two MBT Plants in Portugal (CVO Valorlis and CVO Suldouro) which produce compost-like material are contrasted with the experiences at the MBT Bredbury Parkway (UK) which, by drying the digested solids, produces a RDF with low calorific value for further use in thermal valorisation. The impact of these two different approaches on the operating costs for the treatment of the digested solids as well as the environmental aspects for both valorization paths is discussed.

Post-treatment of Composting Leachate by Photocatalytic Process
© Wasteconsult International (5/2015)
In this study the capability of UV-ZnO photocatalytic process as a post Treatment method for composting leachate was examined at laboratory scale and in batch mode. The effect of some factors such as initial pH, oxidant concentration, light intensity and reaction time on the removal of organic load and color of leachate were investigated. Biological pre-treated leachate samples were collected from the effluent of leachate treatment facility of a composting plant in north of Iran. A Plexiglas column with 110 mm inner diameter and 300 mm height were used to conduct experiments. UVC lamps with different power levels in the range of 8-40W at the centre of the column were used as the source of irradiation. Based on the results of experiments, after 180 minutes of Radiation with 32W UVC lamps in pH 11 and in the presence of 1g.L-1 of slurry ZnO, maximum COD and color removal were achieved to be 57% and 67%, respectively.



 Angemeldet bleiben

Passwort vergessen?

Der ASK Wissenspool
Mit Klick auf die jüngste Ausgabe des Content -Partners zeigt sich das gesamte Angebot des Partners

Selbst Partner werden?
Dann interessiert Sie sicher das ASK win - win Prinzip:
ASK stellt kostenlos die Abwicklungs- und Marketingplattform - die Partner stellen den Content.
Umsätze werden im Verhältnis 30 zu 70 (70% für den Content Partner) geteilt.

Neu in ASK? Dann gleich registrieren und Vorteile nutzen...