Proposals on Carbon-related Border Adjustments: Prospects for WTO Compliance
Recently the practice of border adjustment in international trade has attracted much interest in the context of climate change. The risk of carbon leakage, the competitive disadvantage of industries in countries introducing a cap on emissions and the desire to induce large greenhouse gases emitting countries to join international climate change mitigation actions are the main reasons for considering import restrictions on products with high carbon footprint originating from uncapped nations.
The aim of this paper is to examine current proposals on emissions-related border adjustment measures – tabled in the EU and the US – using the WTO legal framework on border adjustment and detect possible legal flaws which could lead to conflict with WTO law in the future. Special scrutiny is given to the proposals on the requirement for importers to submit emission allowances at the border and allowance rebates on exportation. The key questions are whether regulatory distinction between products based on their carbon content is permissible under the national treatment obligation of Article III of the GATT and whether an emission allowance requirement can qualify as an indirect tax acceptable for adjustment. The test on WTO compliance presented in this paper shows that proposals to include imports in national cap-and-trade systems and suggestions on emissions allowance rebates on exports are vulnerable to WTO challenge. The weaknesses of an emission allowance requirement for importers lie in the peculiarities of an mission allowance requirement as a quasi-tax linked to non-incorporated Processes and Production Methods (PPMs), in the criteria chosen for import coverage or exclusions and in the implementation details. Proposals on allowance rebates contradict environmental objectives and risk getting in conflict with WTO rules on subsidies.
| Copyright: | © Lexxion Verlagsgesellschaft mbH | |
| Quelle: | Issue 1/2010 (April 2010) | |
| Seiten: | 14 | |
| Preis inkl. MwSt.: | € 41,65 | |
| Autor: | Kateryna Holzer  | |
| Artikel weiterleiten | In den Warenkorb legen
| Artikel kommentieren |
Diese Fachartikel könnten Sie auch interessieren:
bifa-Text Nr. 45: Anpassung an den Klimawandel: eine Befragung oberbayerischer Unternehmen
© bifa Umweltinstitut GmbH (3/2010)
Das bifa Umweltinstitut untersuchte, in welchem Umfang sich oberbayerische Unternehmen vom Klimawandel betroffen fühlen, welche Aspekte dabei eine Rolle spielen und ob die Anpassung an die unvermeidbaren Folgen ein Thema ist.
Institutional Mechanisms to Address the AAU Reserves in a Post-2012 Agreement
© Lexxion Verlagsgesellschaft mbH (10/2009)
Russia, Ukraine, Poland, and some other countries will have large surpluses of Assigned Amount Units (AAUs) in the first commitment period of the Kyoto Protocol (2008-2012). This is likely to emerge as one of the central challenges during the post-2012 negotiations. This article proposes a mechanism for addressing the issue through an International AAU Reserve Fund that would facilitate acceptance of more stringent emission reduction commitments by the developed countries post-2012 based on the AAUs reserve accumulated pre-2012.
bifa-Text Nr. 42: CDM - Clean Development Mechanism in the waste management sector
© bifa Umweltinstitut GmbH (10/2009)
An analysis of potentials and barriers within the present methodological framework
Conclusiones de la Jornada sobre Sostenibilidad y Energías Renovables en Andalucia
© INIEC (6/2007)
La jornada sobre Sostenibilidad y Energías Renovables en Andalucía organizada por el Instituto de Investigaciones Ecológicas y que se ha celebrado en la sede del Parque Tecnológico de Andalucía, ha servido para definir las actuaciones estratégicas que se llevarán a cabo, en los próximos años, en esta Comunidad Autónoma con el objetivo de conseguir su independencia energética.
Geothermische Wärme – ein praxisbezogener Überblick Premium
© wvgw Wirtschafts- und Verlagsgesellschaft Gas und Wasser mbH (6/2007)
In Neu- und Altbauten sind geothermische Heizungssysteme gefragte Substitute für die konventionelle Öl- und Gasverfeuerung. Das Interesse an dieser sparsamen und klimafreundlichen Raumwärmebereitstellung richtet sich nunmehr auf das gesamte Spektrum der nutzbaren Umweltenergien und ihre Kombination. Dabei eröffnen die Integration solarthermischer Module und kontrollierte Lüftungssysteme in erdreichgekoppelte Wärmepumpensysteme ungeahnte Möglichkeiten.
